On June 9, 2021, the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) released a draft report titled DNA Mixture Interpretation: A Scientific Foundation Review. This report, open for public comment until August 9, 2021, provides an in-depth evaluation of methods used by forensic laboratories to interpret DNA evidence from mixtures containing genetic material from two or more individuals.
Why Scientific Foundation Reviews Matter
NIST’s scientific foundation reviews aim to evaluate the scientific underpinnings of forensic methodologies. These reviews address gaps highlighted in the 2009 National Academy of Sciences report, which revealed that many forensic disciplines lack robust scientific validation. This particular review underscores the challenges and complexities of interpreting DNA mixtures, emphasizing the need for more publicly accessible data to assess the reliability of current practices.
Insights into Probabilistic Genotyping Systems (PGS)
Probabilistic Genotyping Systems (PGS) play a critical role in interpreting complex DNA mixtures. These systems utilize advanced statistical calculations to separate and identify contributors in mixed DNA profiles. However, the NIST report notes that while numerous peer-reviewed studies exist, they lack detailed data that could enable independent performance assessments of PGS systems.
There is not enough publicly available data to enable an external and independent assessment of the degree of reliability of DNA mixture interpretation practices, including the use of probabilistic genotyping software (PGS) systems – NIST review.
Currently, forensic laboratories conduct internal validation studies on their systems, but concerns about genetic privacy often prevent this data from being shared publicly. The report recommends publishing this data in standardized formats to facilitate cross-comparison and improve transparency.
Challenges in DNA Mixture Interpretation
DNA profiling generally yields reliable results when a single individual’s DNA is present in sufficient quantity. However, interpreting DNA mixtures poses significant challenges:
- Increased Sensitivity of Modern Methods: Advances in DNA technology now allow the detection of “touch DNA,” left behind by handling objects like doorknobs or firearms. While this increases the scope of evidence, it also raises the likelihood of detecting DNA from unrelated individuals.
- Complexity of Mixtures: Determining the number of contributors in a mixture, separating their DNA profiles, and evaluating their relevance to a crime are intricate tasks. Misinterpretations can lead to confusion about the evidence’s strength and relevance.
As NIST Fellow and lead author John Butler stated, “Estimating how many individuals contributed to a DNA mixture, distinguishing one person’s DNA from another, and determining if the DNA is even relevant to the crime can be very challenging.”
“If not properly considered and communicated, these issues can lead to misunderstandings regarding the strength and relevance of the DNA evidence in a case.”
Key Recommendations
The NIST review emphasizes:
- Data Sharing: Researchers and forensic laboratories should publish data to enable independent performance assessments of PGS systems and facilitate comparisons across studies.
- Limits of Methods: Laboratories must establish and communicate the limitations of DNA mixture interpretation to avoid overestimating the strength of evidence.
- Relevance of DNA: Experts should carefully assess whether DNA evidence is connected to the crime, particularly when analyzing minute amounts of DNA.
Future Directions
This report is part of NIST’s broader forensic science program, which aims to improve forensic practices through research and standards development. Future reviews will address firearms examination, digital evidence, and bitemark analysis. By identifying research priorities and recommending limitations on forensic methodologies, NIST strives to advance the reliability and transparency of forensic science.
Public Involvement and Webinar
NIST invites public feedback on the draft report until August 9, 2021. A webinar discussing the findings will be held on July 21, 2021. Instructions for submitting comments and registering for the webinar are available on the NIST website.
More Read
Conclusion
NIST’s review of DNA mixture interpretation marks a pivotal moment in forensic science, addressing critical gaps in transparency and reliability. As the field advances, embracing these recommendations will ensure that DNA evidence continues to be a cornerstone of accurate and trustworthy forensic investigations.
