The Missing Piece Episode 5: Darrell Splett (McHenry County John Doe)

How advanced DNA profiling and genealogical research identified Darrell Splett as McHenry County John Doe. A forensic human-identification case.

1 Min Read

Identification outcome: In May 2019, a man whose identity was unknown was found in the Rush Creek Conservation Area near Harvard, Illinois. After conventional identification attempts and a later genealogy-assisted investigation, authorities announced in October 2020 that he was Darrell P. Splett, 50, of Ingleside. The county coroner’s office reported that his death was not suspicious.

Watch Episode 5: The Missing Piece

Original video credit: ISHI News and Othram. The editorial analysis on this page was independently prepared by Simply Forensic.

https://youtu.be/am8QmytZHeM

A case of unidentified remains, not an unsolved murder

The discovery of a deceased person outdoors creates several separate questions. Investigators must document and examine the remains, establish identity, consider the interval since death and determine whether anything indicates criminal involvement. In this case, the fact that the deceased man was unknown did not mean that a homicide had occurred.

Splett was found wearing winter clothing, including several layers and cold-weather accessories. Coroner’s staff and partner agencies pursued a series of identification methods. Fingerprints, dental records, database searches and facial reconstruction did not initially generate a successful lead.

Traditional forensic approaches

Reports from the McHenry County Coroner’s Office described searches of state, federal and local identification resources, together with STR and mitochondrial DNA testing. Neither set of conventional results produced a confirmed identity at that stage. Digital forensic facial reconstruction was also attempted to solicit recognition.

These methods address different kinds of evidence. Fingerprint records can give a direct comparison if a usable known print exists. Dental comparisons depend on accessible antemortem dental records. STR and mitochondrial profiles support genetic comparison or kinship analyses, but their usefulness depends on reference data and the discriminatory power of the marker system. Artistic reconstructions are investigative aids and cannot independently establish identity.

In 2020, the Coroner’s Office collaborated with Othram on testing of skeletal evidence to generate genetic genealogy leads. Results were returned to Chief Deputy Coroner Olivia Zednick and her team. Through genealogical research, investigators located possible relatives and conducted family-reference testing.

Published accounts state that the DNA evidence supported a sibling relationship with the potential relatives. This confirmation, considered alongside case information, established the unknown man’s identity as Darrell P. Splett. It also enabled authorities to notify his family.

Importantly, a genealogical lead pointing toward relatives should be distinguished from a formal identification. A family tree may narrow the search but can contain incomplete or erroneous information. Appropriate comparative testing provides a separate source of evidence for the identity hypothesis.

What was the case outcome?

McHenry County authorities publicly identified Splett in October 2020. According to contemporary reporting of the coroner’s announcement, the death was considered non-suspicious and the case was closed. The original case did not involve identification of a violent offender, and it should not be framed as a homicide solved through genetic genealogy.

This illustrates the broader humanitarian role of advanced DNA methods. Restoring the identity of deceased people and giving families reliable answers is a forensic objective in its own right, independent of criminal prosecution.

What forensic scientists should take from the case

  • Keep identity and manner of death separate: an unidentified deceased person is not automatically a homicide victim.
  • Use multiple comparison systems: fingerprint, dental, STR, mtDNA and genome-wide kinship data may each contribute different evidence.
  • Do not overstate mtDNA: people in the same maternal lineage may share a mitochondrial sequence, limiting individual identification from mtDNA alone.
  • Understand reference availability: a negative database search may reflect an absent record, not a failed laboratory analysis.
  • Confirm the genealogy lead: family samples, kinship statistics and independent records can test a proposed identity.

A broader lesson in human identification

Documenting unsuccessful early tests is valuable: it clarifies why different methods were attempted, prevents duplicate work and preserves an audit trail. The goal is not to credit one technology with doing everything. Human identification often depends on collaboration between coroners, forensic scientists, genealogists, family members and other investigative partners.

Frequently asked questions

Was Darrell Splett’s death a homicide?

The McHenry County Coroner’s Office reportedly classified the death as non-suspicious. This episode concerns identification of human remains rather than solving a murder.

How was his identity established?

DNA genealogy developed possible family leads. Investigators followed these leads and used family-reference testing to confirm the identity.

Why were earlier STR or mtDNA tests insufficient?

They did not produce an informative database association. A result can be technically valid yet not identify someone if relevant reference samples are unavailable.

References and video credits

  1. ISHI News, original Episode 5 (23 September 2021)
  2. Lake & McHenry County Scanner, coroner’s identification announcement (23 October 2020)
  3. National Human Genome Research Institute, investigative genomics primer
  4. National Institute of Justice, forensic genealogy introduction

The Missing Piece is an ISHI News/Othram production. This is independent Simply Forensic forensic case commentary, not a transcript or an official account from the filmmakers. Reviewed 15 November 2026.

More videos in this series

Explore the complete The Missing Piece video guide.

Share This Article
Follow:
Forensic Analyst by Profession. With Simplyforensic.com striving to provide a one-stop-all-in-one platform with accessible, reliable, and media-rich content related to forensic science. Education background in B.Sc.Biotechnology and Master of Science in forensic science.
Leave a Comment