Updated 15 November 2026. The Missing Piece is a forensic science video project produced by the International Symposium on Human Identification (ISHI) in collaboration with Othram. The series introduces the investigators, scientists and families involved in cold cases and unidentified-person investigations where forensic DNADNA, or Deoxyribonucleic Acid, is the genetic material found in cells, composed of a double helix structure. It serves as the genetic blueprint for all Read Full Definition analysis and genetic genealogy provided new leads. This Simply Forensic guide brings together our original commentary on six episodes, with up-to-date case outcomes, embedded videos, scientific explanations and source references.
- Watch The Missing Piece: introduction
- Explore the six case episodes
- What is forensic investigative genetic genealogy?
- Two investigative applications: identifying offenders and identifying remains
- What can go wrong in a forensic genealogy investigation?
- Further study: the forensic science behind the cases
- Frequently asked questions
- References and credits
Editorial note: Simply Forensic did not produce the original videos. The commentary and forensic analysis on our linked episode pages are independently written, with the producers credited throughout. A video made in 2021 reflects what was known then; subsequent developments appear in the revised articles.
Watch The Missing Piece: introduction
The original series introduction provides background on how genealogy-assisted forensic investigations differ from traditional DNA database searches. Watch the original ISHI News video below, then explore the individual case studies.
Explore the six case episodes
Each article contains the original episode video, an updated independently written case summary, an explanation of the forensic evidence, the case outcome where established, frequently asked questions, sources and links to other episodes.
| Episode | Forensic focus | Read and watch |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Carla Walker | Historical crime-scene DNA; investigative genealogy; guilty plea in 2021 | Episode 1: Carla Walker |
| 2. Lisa Todd | Identification of skeletal remains; severely degraded DNA; suspicious death not definitively resolved | Episode 2: Publicker Girl |
| 3. Rodney Johnson | Tooth-derived DNA; high bacterial background; genealogy and confirmatory family testing | Episode 3: Lake Stickney John Doe |
| 4. Shawna Beth Garber | Identification of “Grace Doe”; later police announcement of clearance by exception in 2024 | Episode 4: Grace Doe |
| 5. Darrell Splett | Unidentified remains; multi-method comparison; death classified as non-suspicious | Episode 5: McHenry County John Doe |
| 6. Mary Catherine Edwards | Cold-case sexual assault and homicide; mixed DNA evidence; 2024 conviction | Episode 6: Mary Catherine Edwards |
What is forensic investigative genetic genealogy?
Investigative genetic genealogy (IGG), also called forensic genetic genealogy or forensic genetic genealogical DNA analysis and searching (FGGS), combines genome-wide DNA information with genetic-relative matching, genealogy records and conventional investigation. It often becomes relevant when a DNA profile cannot be associated with a known individual through standard comparison procedures.
Ordinary forensic STR profiling and genealogy-oriented SNP analysis are not the same process. STR systems target selected repetitive genetic regions and may be searched against forensic databases such as CODIS when appropriate. Genealogy analysis typically uses hundreds of thousands of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) distributed across the genome. The resulting data can be compared through genealogy services that permit the particular investigative use under their conditions and applicable law.
A simplified investigative workflow
- Evaluate the forensic sample: confirm its provenance, relevance, extraction potential, contributor complexity and availability for further testing.
- Conduct suitable conventional profiling: pursue eligible STR comparisons, case records and existing investigative leads.
- Generate genealogy-compatible genetic data: when authorised and technically feasible, carry out SNP-oriented profiling and quality assessment.
- Search appropriate databases: investigate genetic matches only through permitted services and under the relevant laws and policies.
- Build and test relationships: construct family-tree hypotheses and corroborate them with independent civil records and case facts.
- Confirm the proposed identity: for an alleged offender, conduct appropriate direct forensic comparisons; for unidentified remains, obtain family-reference samples and perform suitable kinship analysis.
A relationship lead is not a DNA identification on its own. Genetic relatives may share substantial genomic segments without being involved in a crime. Genealogical inference must be distinguished from direct evidential comparison and from any assessment of how or when biological material was deposited.
Two investigative applications: identifying offenders and identifying remains
The Missing Piece episodes illustrate why the use of genetic genealogy should not be described solely as a method for “catching criminals.” Carla Walker and Mary Catherine Edwards involve identification of alleged offenders in homicide investigations. Lisa Todd, Rodney Johnson, Shawna Beth Garber and Darrell Splett illustrate another application: restoring the identities of deceased people.
Those latter cases have differing investigative outcomes. Rodney Johnson’s death was a homicide, but identifying him did not automatically identify his killer. Lisa Todd’s death was regarded as suspicious, while authorities initially could not establish how it occurred. Darrell Splett’s death was not considered suspicious. Shawna Beth Garber’s identification was followed years later by investigators publicly naming a deceased suspect and clearing the case by exception. These differences are essential for accurate reporting.
What can go wrong in a forensic genealogy investigation?
- Degraded or contaminated evidence: skeletal material may yield little human DNA amid substantial environmental or bacterial DNA.
- Mixed profiles: more than one contributor can complicate interpretation and suitability for downstream investigation.
- Database limitations: the database may not contain informative relatives; genetic coverage and representation vary.
- Incorrect genealogy: family trees can be affected by adoption, unknown parentage, incomplete documents or misattributed relationships.
- Overstated conclusions: shared DNA and genealogical proximity do not, without further evidence, establish individual identity or criminal culpability.
- Privacy and consent: genetic data can implicate relatives who never personally uploaded profiles, so database policies and legal authority must be respected.
Further study: the forensic science behind the cases
Students and practitioners can use these videos alongside technical material on SNPs and forensic genetic genealogy, genetic genealogy privacy and legislation, and the Golden State Killer investigation. These readings offer scientific, evidential and policy context that short video episodes cannot cover fully.
Frequently asked questions
Who created The Missing Piece?
The video series was developed by ISHI News in collaboration with Othram. Simply Forensic embeds the original videos and publishes separate educational case commentary.
Does this page contain the full official series?
This hub presents the six episodes currently covered on Simply Forensic. For the original producers’ collection, visit the official video playlist.
Does an investigative genealogy match prove someone committed a crime?
No. The match helps develop a lead or hypothesis. Independent comparison, investigative corroboration and consideration of how evidence was deposited are necessary before making an evidential conclusion.
Why not simply search CODIS?
An STR database search is often an important early step, but can return no useful identity association if a relevant profile is absent. Genome-wide SNP genealogy uses a different data type and can detect more distant biological relationships under applicable restrictions.
Are all these episodes homicide cases?
No. Some concern unidentified remains, including the Darrell Splett case, which was reported as a non-suspicious death. The purpose of genetic identification varies across the series.
References and credits
- ISHI News: announcement of The Missing Piece video project (2020).
- The Missing Piece: video playlist.
- National Institute of Justice (2022): forensic genetic genealogy technology for forensic providers.
- National Human Genome Research Institute: investigative genomics.
- US Department of Justice: policy principles and scientific-investigative boundaries.
Video ownership: ISHI News and Othram. All episode case commentary, explanations, FAQs and cross-references are original Simply Forensic educational material. Reviewed 15 November 2026.



